Introduction: Despite decades of investment, stream restoration often fails to recover diverse benthic macroinvertebrate communities, as restored reaches tend to remain dominated by pollution-tolerant taxa. This shortfall in recovery is commonly attributed to either poor habitat quality or dispersal limitation of aquatic macroinvertebrate taxa, yet these hypotheses are rarely tested directly. Objectives: We conducted a manipulative field experiment in the eastern Piedmont region (Maryland, USA) within the Chesapeake Bay Watershed to evaluate whether restored streams can support pollution-sensitive taxa when dispersal barriers are removed. Methods: We translocated whole macroinvertebrate communities from three nearby reference streams into three restored streams using standardized habitat substrates and quantified macroinvertebrate survival after 28 days. We also assessed how effective leaf vs rock substrates were for accumulating diverse and abundant macroinvertebrate communities for translocation. Results: Across all sites, 77% of translocated individuals and 16 of 22 taxa sensitive and moderately sensitive to pollution persisted under restored stream conditions, demonstrating that restored reaches can support short-term survival of pollution-sensitive taxa that typically fail to recover. Substrate comparisons revealed that leaf packs accumulated higher macroinvertebrate abundances, whereas both substrates accumulated macroinvertebrate communities with similar taxa richness, EPT richness, and Shannon Diversity. Conclusions: This work suggests that dispersal limitation, rather than unsuitable habitat, may be an underappreciated constraint limiting macroinvertebrate recovery in restored streams. These findings challenge the assumption that habitat restoration alone is sufficient for biological recovery and highlight the potential for whole-community translocations to accelerate recovery and ecological uplift as part of stream restoration practices. Implication for Practice: Our study highlights the need to consider habitat connectivity and dispersal pathways during stream restoration designs. Restoring streams to meet habitat requirements of pollution-sensitive macroinvertebrate taxa may not be sufficient for their populations to recover if these taxa are unable to reach the restored stream. In scenarios where restoring connectivity to source populations is infeasible, whole community translocations may offer a novel restoration tool to overcome dispersal barriers and accelerate biological recovery in restored streams.
Fagbohun, I. R., Allen, D. C., Sweetman, J. N., Hilderbrand, R. H.
Advertisement
Stats
- Recommendations n/a n/a positive of 0 vote(s)
- Views 1
- Comments 0